Hackney’s move to end its 58-year twinning with Haifa has been branded “destructive and provocative” by Barnet’s ruling Labour group, as the neighbouring borough voted to explore a link of its own with the Israeli city.
At the same meeting (20 October), Barnet Council voted to open talks with Haifa about a twinning relationship, backing a Conservative motion that describes the Hackney Green administration’s decision as “shameful”.

The motion, in the name of Cllr Raffy Lachter, was carried by 29 votes to one at Tuesday’s full council meeting at Hendon Town Hall. Labour councillors, who run the borough, did not vote.
In a statement published on the night, Barnet Labour party said it “considers Hackney’s decision to be a destructive and provocative move, which will alienate many Jewish residents of Hackney”.
The motion also states that the Hackney-Haifa link is “due to end 14 October 2026”. However, that is not the case: Hackney has not yet taken a final decision, and 14 October was only the revised closing date for residents’ views.
Hackney's review
Hackney’s twinning with Haifa was signed in September 1968 by the then Mayor of Hackney, Stanley Clinton Davis, and his Haifa counterpart, Abba Hushi.
At full council on 28 July, Hackney’s Green administration – which won 42 of the borough’s 57 seats in May – agreed in principle to end the agreement, subject to an engagement exercise and a full equality impact assessment.

Cllr Sam Mathys (Green party, Clissold ward), the cabinet member for culture, told the chamber at the time: “It is our responsibility as a Green-led council to ensure that our institutional relationships are consistent with our values and commitment to human rights, international law, justice and international solidarity.”
Labour and Conservative councillors in Hackney opposed the move, warning it would damage community relations.
A six-member cross-party working group chaired by Cllr Mathys is reviewing all five of Hackney’s twinning arrangements and is due to report back to full council in January. Legal advice in the July report recommends giving Haifa at least three months’ notice.
The Hackney Citizen revealed earlier this month that officers brought the closing date for views forward to 7 October, the anniversary of the Hamas attacks on Israel.
The Barnet Conservative party motion
The motion does not twin the two places. It resolves to invite the Mayor of Haifa and the city’s municipality into discussions “with a view to establishing a twinning relationship”, covering healthcare, higher education and interfaith work.

Council officers have been asked to examine the potential benefits, costs, governance arrangements and practical requirements, and to report back to the next ordinary meeting of full council.
The motion points to Haifa’s Rambam Health Care Campus, which it says serves more than two million people across northern Israel, and to Middlesex University in Barnet alongside the University of Haifa and the Technion.
It also notes that Barnet has the highest number of Jewish residents of any area in the UK – 56,616 people, or 14.5 per cent of the population, at the last census.
The item went to a vote without debate. The Conservatives chose to spend their opposition debate slot on a motion about the London Plan instead.
Labour abstains
Barnet’s Labour group, which holds 31 of the council’s 63 seats, said in a statement published on the night that it had abstained.
It cited the council’s “significant financial challenges”, saying it “cannot vote for a financial commitment which is open-ended in terms of duration”.
The group said the council had turned down other twinning proposals in recent years, with towns in Ukraine and Malaysia, and pointed out that Barnet is already twinned with another Israeli city, Ramat Gan.
But it said it had not voted against “out of respect for Haifa, a multicultural city where both Jews and Arabs are represented in administration and which hosts the international headquarters of the Bahai faith”.
The statement was sharply critical of Hackney, and noted that the Labour leader of Hertsmere, which borders Barnet, had “indicated strongly” that he wants to twin that district with Haifa.
The Barnet Labour party motion
Later the same evening, councillors backed a motion from council leader Cllr Barry Rawlings (Labour party) titled “Antisemitism is Racism”, by 58 votes with one abstention.
It condemns the ‘Zionism is racism’ motion passed by the national Green party at its conference in Brighton on 4 October, and instructs Cllr Rawlings to write to the Green party leader Zack Polanski, setting out the council’s condemnation.
In Labour’s statement, Cllr Rawlings said: “Jewish residents have told us how concerned they are about the Green party policy. It echoes the worst kind of antisemitism that came out of the Soviet Union.
“We want Jewish communities to know that we stand by them, and will not let them be marginalised or ostracised.”
Before the vote, Barnet’s only Green party councillor, Cllr Charli Thompson (Woodhouse), raised a point of order. She said the motion’s claim that the Greens had committed to campaigning against the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) definition of antisemitism and the Jerusalem Declaration was untrue.
“Our adopted policy contains no such commitment,” she said, adding that she could not move amendments “because nobody will second my amendments”. The chair ruled the motion was not improper.
The Green party’s own published summary of the motion makes no mention of either definition. It says the motion defines Zionism as “an ethnonationalist political project” and states that anti-Zionism should not be equated with antisemitism.
'Not a monolith'
Earlier, during public questions, Beau Sebastian – a Green party member, a member of Jewish Greens and, in his own words, “an observant anti-Zionist Jew” – challenged Cllr Rawlings over the motion’s claim that the Green policy had alarmed the majority of Barnet’s Jewish community.
“Jewish people are not a monolith. Some of us are Zionists, some of us are not,” he said, asking how the council had assessed Jewish opinion and why anti-Zionist Jews had not been consulted.
Cllr Rawlings said he had received “80, 90 emails” against the Green policy and cited condemnation from the Board of Deputies, the Chief Rabbi and the Movement for Progressive Judaism, among others.
On consultation, he noted that the Green motion was passed by 1,022 votes in a party he put at 230,000 members. “If the Greens did not want to consult with their own members, your criticism should be with the Green party, and not with me,” he said. The Green party conference motion passed by 1,022 votes to 813.
Find out more on these topics