The Home Office repeatedly contacted Hackney Council officers about a magazine launch in the borough – warning that it could breach terrorism law and asking whether the venue had been told of its concerns – documents show.
The launch of the socialist magazine Tribune’s autumn issue, Empire Now, took place on 4 November at the Rose Lipman Building, a council-owned community arts venue run by the company MillCo.
It featured the Swedish climate academic Andreas Malm and Palestine Action co-founder Huda Ammori, who both spoke by video link.
Ammori spoke on the same day she was in the Supreme Court challenging the proscription of Palestine Action as a terrorist organisation. Judgment has yet to be handed down.
Malm had been barred from the UK days earlier, when the Home Office cancelled his electronic travel authorisation. He was told his presence was “not considered to be conducive to the public good”, and given no further reasons.
Concern
Documents obtained by Tribune through freedom of information and subject access requests show that in an email dated 12 October, an official from the Home Office’s extremism disruptions team told the council that Malm “has made many statements in support of terrorists and direct action, particularly regarding Palestine and climate change.”
A Home Office assessment the following day found the event “unlikely to meet the threshold for disruption”, according to a letter from Hackney mayor Zoë Garbett to the home secretary.
After Malm was barred and Tribune said he would appear by video link instead, officials stepped up their contact. The day before the event, the Home Office emailed the council’s Prevent and hate crime coordinator to describe Malm and Ammori as “two speakers of concern”.
It also shared with officers the intelligence summary used to justify revoking Malm’s travel authorisation, which stated that he “legitimises and encourages attacks on energy infrastructure and terrorism”.
An official from the Home Office’s Prevent local delivery unit told the council: “Ultimately, I can’t direct you to cancel the event. This is a decision for the council.”
But the official went on to warn that the event could breach the Terrorism Act 2000 “whereby it is an offence if a person … assists in arranging … a meeting which he knows is to be addressed by a person who belongs … to a proscribed organisation”. Ammori has not been charged with any offence.
Venue
The Home Office asked to be “updated on any decisions by the local authority”.
On the eve of the event it wrote to the council again: “The Home Office is keen to understand if the council has spoken to anyone at MillCo about the booking, even if it is to take place virtually. Do you know if anyone followed up with [redacted]?”
Hackney officials then contacted MillCo to pass on the Home Office’s concerns. In a later email, one officer wrote: “The Home Office asked us to share the concerns regarding the speaker, which we’ve done.”
According to Tribune editor Oliver Eagleton, a venue manager then rang the magazine to say the event would have to be cancelled.
Intervention
Tribune contacted Garbett, who described the attempted cancellation as “outrageous”. Her office wrote to council officers asking them to reflect the council’s statutory duty to uphold freedom of expression and peaceful assembly to the Home Office, and to ensure the event went ahead without further intervention. The cancellation was then withdrawn.
Garbett has now written to home secretary Shabana Mahmood demanding an explanation, in a letter published by Tribune today.
She writes: “As mayor of Hackney, I am shocked by these actions and the precedent they set. Encouraging the cancellation of lawful public events represents an assault on the right to free speech and under no circumstance will I be complicit in it.”
Questions
The mayor asks the home secretary:
- “On what legal, regulatory, or statutory grounds did Home Office officials contact Hackney Council and venue managers regarding the booking at the Rose Lipman Building, and what specific risk assessment criteria were applied?
- “Given that Home Office communications on 13 October stated the event was ‘unlikely to meet the threshold for disruption,’ and police confirmed there was no indication of local disorder, what specific intelligence or altered assessment prompted the escalation on 2 and 3 November?
- “Why was pressure exerted on local council officers to consider cancelling or vetoing speakers, and how does the Home Office reconcile these actions with local authorities’ statutory obligations to uphold free speech and peaceful assembly under the Human Rights Act?
- “Since 2023, how many public or community events in Hackney concerning climate action, civil liberties, or international policy has the Home Office monitored, gathered intelligence on, or sought to intervene in?”
The letter goes on to cite the borough’s history of protest, from the fight against fascism on Ridley Road in the 1930s to anti-racist campaigns in the 1980s and 1990s.
In an opinion piece in the Guardian today, Garbett writes: “the Labour government is now fixated on petty authoritarianism. Its efforts to stamp out resistance to its foreign policy have become more and more absurd, and its list of targets appears to be growing by the day.”
She adds: “Andy Burnham has done nothing to end this climate of repression. If anything, abuses of power have intensified under his government.”
Denial
The Home Office has denied attempting to cancel the event. A spokesperson told the Guardian it was “categorically untrue” to suggest officials had pushed for its cancellation.
The spokesperson said the department provided Hackney Council with “all available information” so it could make its own independent decision.
The Home Office also pointed to the Prevent duty, which requires public bodies to take steps to reduce environments where radicalisation can take hold.
It said local authorities are advised to work with partners to assess events and speakers where there are potential radicalisation or terrorism-related risks.
Reaction
In a statement, Garbett said: “I am appalled by the Home Office’s attempt to influence decisions made locally in Hackney, and to suppress freedom of expression and assembly within our borough. Hackney has a rich and enduring history of activism and protest – a heritage that we will defend against any government agenda which seeks to undermine basic democratic rights.”
Eagleton said: “This government is so desperate to cover up its complicity in genocide that it targeted a small community arts centre for hosting an event about Palestine. But we refused to be intimidated – and the bullying tactics of the Home Office ended in abject failure.”
Malm said: “The UK’s crackdown on free expression is terrifying. First they ban the books of Sally Rooney. Then they block people like me from entering the country because of our support for Palestine. Now it comes to light that they tried to cancel this magazine launch – just because they feared that the speakers might say something they disagree with. Where will this repression end?”
Ammori, who is awaiting the Supreme Court’s decision on her challenge to the proscription, said: “The proscription of a protest group as a terrorist organisation for the first time in British history has unleashed an unprecedented assault on free speech in this country. By trying to prevent me from being able to speak publicly, the Home Office has further proven the case I was making in the Supreme Court that same day about the authorities misapplying the law to carry out unlawful arrests and unlawful acts of censorship such as this.
“Home Office officials wrongly advised the council that this entirely lawful political discussion would breach the Terrorism Act simply because I was due to participate. I have never been convicted of any crime, let alone a terrorism offence, but people convicted under the Terrorism Act are not gagged as a result and barred from speaking publicly. The suggestion that my participation in a political discussion could somehow make that discussion unlawful is ludicrous – the very day I was speaking freely in the Supreme Court – and would be laughable were it not such a sinister and scary attack on fundamental freedoms.”
Find out more on these topics